Florida's natural springs in crisis: Which ones are cleanest, most polluted?

Time running out this session for bill aimed at repairing, protecting Florida's aquatic gems

Fanning Springs had a lush garden of native underwater plants when the artesian jewel became a state park a little more than a decade ago.

Today, a witch's hairdo of algae dominates Fanning's waters. About 35 miles from Gainesville, the cluster of springs has earned recognition as among the state's most polluted and a prime example of what's killing ecosystems at many of Florida's best-known springs.

Sweeping water legislation aimed in large part at repairing and protecting springs across the state is pending in Tallahassee, marking at least the fifth year in a row of serious attempts to bolster safeguards for one of Florida's environmental treasures. But with just three weeks left in the current legislative session, it is unclear whether this year's bill finally will succeed.

"This is the biggest change in water law in at least 20 years," said state Sen. Lee Constantine, R- Altamonte Springs, the author of SB 550. "When you do something like that, it's always dicey."

Ecosystem disasters have been emerging at the biggest of nearly 700 known Florida springs, including Wakulla near Tallahassee; the most iconic, such as the mermaid playground at Weeki Wachee north of Tampa Bay; and even ones as highly protected as the Wekiwa near Orlando.

In essence, complex and rich arrangements of aquatic plants, fish and wildlife are being snuffed out by simple but overwhelming forms of algae.

The culprit is an extremely common type of water pollution, soaking deep into the ground from a variety of sources, including septic tanks, sewage plants, agriculture, lawn fertilizer and dirty stormwater. It's called nitrate, a form of nitrogen and an essential nutrient for plant growth.

Peer into the massive pool created by Silver Springs near Ocala, and to the untrained eye there's not much sign that anything is wrong.

Even through the glass bottoms of the vintage Yahalochee and Charlie Cypress tour boats, the basin seems to thrive with turtles, fish and long, skinny plants that look like giant blades of grass.

Scientists suspect, however, appearances are deceiving at Silver Springs.

Bob Knight, University of Florida professor and springs researcher for 30 years, and other aquatic scientists have documented how rising nitrate levels initially act as a growth booster for a spring's plants and then wreak havoc.

Alexander Springs, deep in Ocala National Forest, is possibly the state's cleanest — nearly what Mother Nature originally designed — with a nitrate level of far less than 1 part per million and measuring consistently at about 0.05 parts per million. That tells scientists healthy springs have extremely low levels of nitrate.

Serious harm begins in a range of 0.2 to 0.4 parts per million of nitrate. At that point, native spring plants are getting force-fed a high-calorie diet. The signature vegetation of healthy springs — eelgrass and tape grass — surges with growth.

The nitrate level at Silver Springs has pushed to 1.4 parts per million and is still rising.

"At higher concentrations, what we see is a flip where the system stops supporting the submerged aquatic vegetation — like the tape grass and the eelgrass — and it starts supporting more and more algae and a different kind of algae: filamentous algae," Knight said, referring to the type that looks like an unruly wig.

"The thickness of these algae mats can be a foot or more, and it totally replaces submerged plants," he said.

Knight studied under one of Florida's earliest springs scientists, Howard Odum, and has at his fingertips a half-century of data on Silver Springs biology and chemistry. He fears the system is vulnerable to that flip.

At Fanning Springs, the nitrate level is about 6 parts per million, which approaches a concentration too toxic to drink. The loss of eelgrass and related variety of other plants was relatively sudden, leaving an ecosystem "pretty much sterile" compared with the flora and fauna once in place, said park manager Sally Lieb.

At Wekiwa Springs, where algae growth is rampant, nitrate levels often exceed 1 part per million.

Knight thinks if dramatic action were taken to prevent nitrate from getting into springs — for example, by connecting septic tanks to modern sewage systems and limiting use of farm fertilizers in sensitive areas — the problem would still persist because of the heavy load of pollutant now stored in the aquifer system that supplies water to springs.

"The springs are just the tip of the iceberg," he said. "We've got a Floridan Aquifer contamination issue with nitrate. It's going to take years, even if you stopped fertilizing in Florida, for rain to rinse that nitrate out."

There is evidence springs can be salvaged. Nitrate in Wekiwa Springs, for example, has lessened slightly as a result of closure of the massive farms around Lake Apopka and the decline of the area's citrus industry.

The city of Tallahassee has been revamping the way it disposes of treated sewage in an attempt to lessen nitrate turning up in waters of Wakulla Springs.

"It's worth noting we are already seeing improvements," said Michael Sole, secretary of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection and a strong supporter of most of Constantine's water bill.

Late last week, Constantine held a six-hour meeting in Tallahassee with bill opponents, including representatives of farming, construction and other industries. He agreed to consider modifying some of the bill's provisions, which include measures to improve septic tanks, reform stormwater regulations, establish springs-protection zones and put Florida on a path to adopting more-precise water-quality standards. He also is working to align his legislation with various sections of water legislation in the House.

The bill is slated for one more committee stop before advancing to the Senate floor for debate.

"We've got a good shot," Constantine said. "A lot better shot than we did last year."

Kevin Spear can be reached at kspear@orlandosentinel.com or 407-420-5062.

Source: http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/local/os-floridas-dying-springs-20100411,0,7837975.story

About Oceanic Defense
We are an international non-profit organization with members in over 60 countries, spanning 6 continents with 1 mission; healthy aquatic ecosystems free from human abuse and neglect. Oceanic Defense teaches people to protect our oceans by acting responsibly as consumers and by making smart decisions in our daily lives. Whether we are buying groceries, commuting to work, planning a vacation or advocating within our own communities; each action we take or decision we make either helps or hurts our oceans. We empower people to be part of the solution rather than part of the problem and work together to protect our blue planet.

Join us on Facebook:
Visit our official website:
Follow us on Twitter:


  1. In the Wekiva area there are hundreds of dump sites. In the Silver Springs area there are too many sources to count that FDEP has authorized to dump. Who is kidding whom? How can FDEP and DCA officials pretend they don't know about all the drainage points that they have authorized to discharge high nutrient effluent into the ground water?

    It appears that a great deal of FDEP budget is used to cover-up the hundreds of effluent dump sites. Many who have studied FDEP's apparent state of denial wonder if the average citizen cares about the misleading nature of the Springs Protection effort by FDEP. Is distrust of government so great that the state agency who is charged with figuring out how pollution is getting to our springs, is the same agency authorizing hundreds of dump points dumping millions of gallons of pollution directly up stream our springs?

    Many who have been blaming septic tanks in order to stop growth or promote city cash cow public utilities will now have to prove it or give up the push. Marion County Health officials reported at the public hearing that Dosing Septic Systems are of no extra value in reducing nitrates. The extra cost for citizens will have to be justified before the plan to add new electric septic tanks can go forward.

    Hundreds of monster drainage points operated by utilities plague the Springs Protection Plan. It is not possible to discise the dumping that comes from utilities, experts point out."

    FDEP set the limit for drainage wells at 10.0 mg/L. That is 10 times the level Wekiva is currently struggling with for Nitrates. High-permeability aquifer systems with karst conduits connecting dump hot spots with the springs are quickly transferring pollutants to our springs.

    Don Browning explains that the drinking water standard level for nitrates is very misleading if used for springs, because humans can tolerate 10 parts of nitrate per million but springs are destroyed by just 1 part per million. Nitrogen promotes growth in plants and we must stop blaming the public for utilities who continue to dump contaminated fluids into our springs.

    Billions of gallons of Storm Sewer pollutants are directed to the Springs via karst underground conduits. We wouldn't know about the underground contamination if it were not for the springs. Nitrates would go unnoticed if it were not for the clear waters of the springs where sunlight can penetrate to grow algae in the high nitrate solution.

    FDEP, and those who operate under funding and regulatory control of FDEP have switched to Outfall Recharge as the name of Dumping Storm Sewer Runoff into a water body or hiding the pollution underground in an Aquifer.

    Tricks such as counting nitrates before treatment in the Drain field of a on site Treatment Plant, and After treatment in a Utility Treatment Plant. Legislators are stunned when attending a class by Team Conservation to learn to understand FDEP deceptive communication techniques. Breaking the DEP Code is Job One. We are getting a translation out to the people. You can help. FDEP employees and the Director Mike Sole are not directly responsible. They have come into an agency with a culture of deception that has grown up over the years. The Collective, Bureaucracy is actually in control. Teams of Lawyers, Directors and managers all must do their part to keep the deception alive

  2. I really like going to this spring it is one of the cleanest springs i have been to.